The 7 Best Sporting Goods Stores in New Jersey!

Whether you’re looking for a baseball glove, a pair of soccer cleats, or a basketball, the great locally-owned sporting goods stores of New Jersey stock all of that and more. It doesn’t matter if you’re just starting out in your sport or you’re a seasoned vet, there’s something for everyone. At these shops, you’ll find a highly-knowledgeable staff with a passion for sports that matches yours. Here are the 7 best in the state. 

Birkenmeier Sport Shop, Hackensack, NJ

Birkenmeier Sport Shop opened in 1982 as a small soccer gear store, but due to its popularity, it has since expanded to a sports store specialized in soccer gear and apparel from international brands. They carry numerous types of soccer shoes and uniforms. The owner of the store is a former professional soccer player for the Cosmos, so you can feel passion for soccer throughout the store and in the staff.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by SEFT LLC (@seftraining) on

Thompson Sporting Goods, Summit, NJ

Offering both brick and mortar and online shopping, Thompson Sporting Goods has your convenience in mind. Their specialty is school-offered sports, like lacrosse, baseball, and volleyball, so kids can pick up the gear needed for after school sports or a lost jersey just in time for the next game. They also offer screen printing and embroidery on-site.

Sports Expert, Hillsdale, NJ

Sports Expert is a family-owned and operated sporting goods store that stocks whatever you need for school or extra-curricular sports. They carry sneakers, cleats, and apparel for nine sports. In addition, they offer custom uniform, embroidery, and silk screening for custom jersey or sports apparel orders. 

Alfred’s Sports Shop, Madison, NJ

This privately-owned sporting goods store stocks gear, uniforms, and varsity jackets. Shop online or in-store for track and field, football, soccer, baseball, and hockey gear and apparel. They also offer screen printing and embroidery for customizing uniforms or creating a new team look.

Middlebury Sports & Apparel, Randolph, NJ

Middlebury Sports & Apparel offers something a bit different—a buyers’ club that allows members to get discounted prices and access to the best sporting goods. This is appropriate for serious athletes who need to purchase near gear frequently and their staff can help you find exactly what it is that you need. They carry all the major brands, yet membership gets you special prices.

A post shared by @middleburysports on

The Sport Spot NJ, Shrewsbury, NJ

The Sport Spot NJ has been focused on swim, snow, and tennis supplies since its opening in 1970. They stock skiing and snowboarding brands such as Atomic, Roxy, Full Tilt, Burton, and K2, so they’ll have you covered on the slopes. If cold weather sports aren’t your thing, they carry both competitive and leisurely swimwear, and offer a full-service tennis center that can fix rackets and more.

Pegasus Soccer Sporting Goods Inc., Newark, NJ

Pegasus Soccer Sporting Goods Inc. is one for serious soccer fans. They carry the jerseys and apparel of the Portuguese League and National Team as well as other European, North American, and South American teams. They also carry a selection footwear for adults and children.

Share your favorites!
New Jersey Search
Find Sporting Goods Stores Near You
Select a New Jersey town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you