The 10 Best Historic Theaters in New Jersey!

In the 1920s, vaudevillian theaters were all the rage in the United States, and numerous theaters popped up throughout the country. These theaters were the home of cultural performances and community events, yet many of them suffered during the rise of talking pictures and again with the competition of cinema multiplexes. However, those that have survived or have been rejuvenated are seeing an influx of visitors interested in watching and learning about the performing arts. These are New Jersey’s most notable venues to watch plays, musicals, and live performances.

1. Edison Valley Playhouse, Edison, NJ

The Edison Valley Playhouse was first established in 1895, and is a beautiful red building with striking historic architecture. It has served as a venue for live entertainment as well as performing arts education. It continues to show performances including frequent Coffee House Comedy variety shows.

A post shared by Paul (@therealpaulcory) on

2. State Theatre New Jersey, New Brunswick, NJ

The State Theatre is a vaudevillian and silent film theater opened in 1921. In 2004, this already beautiful theater underwent renovations and restorations to improve New Jersey’s second largest theater. Enter the gilded interior, sit down on a red velvet seat, and enjoy a concert, musical, ballet, or children’s theater.

3. Broadway Theatre of Pitman, Pitman, NJ

This French Revival theater was opened in May 1926 to showcase vaudeville theater to local visitors. The front features eye-catching neon lights and the interior is intricately designed with murals and red velvet curtains. Still in-use today, it features concerts and children’s performances.

4. The Strand Center for the Arts, Lakewood, NJ

This historic theater was opened in 1922 and has had numerous stars gracing its stage since. Its fantastic design encouraged Broadway producers to test performances here prior to their release in New York City and it is still appreciated for its excellent acoustics. Due to its great preservation, The Strand has been included on the National Register of Historic Places and has recently been restored. The schedule is packed with numerous events and activities.

5. Count Basie Theatre, Red Bank, NJ

Established in 1926, the Count Basie Theatre has seen numerous stars, such as Art Garfunkel, praise the stage. Though originally opened as Reade’s Carlton, the name of the theater was changed to honor a famous local musician, Count Basie, who performed at JFK’s inauguration. This theatre is also on the National Register of Historic Places. Count Basie Theatre currently runs as a non-profit performing arts venue and educational center.

6. Brook Arts, Bound Brook, NJ

The Brook Arts is the oldest theater in the county and originally opened in 1927 during the height of the popularity of movie palaces. The Brook Arts has remained unchanged (though it has been restored) from its time as a vaudevillian theater and has great acoustics, brilliant chandeliers, and intricate carvings. The theater still shows several original plays and musical performances throughout the year.

7. The Landmark Loew’s Jersey Theater, Jersey City, NJ

The Landmark Loew’s Jersey Theater opened in 1929 and featured stunning interiors with intricately designed carvings and frescoes. The theater was completely refurbished and restored in the 1990s from its severely neglected state. Now, you can see the resorted original chandeliers and the brilliant marquee when shows are performed. The Landmark Loew’s Theater is currently battling to stay open, but their enthusiastic supporters are working to keep the historic theater alive.

A post shared by The New JSQ (@newjsq) on

8. Paper Mill Playhouse, Milburn, NJ

The Paper Mill Playhouse’s first life was as a paper mill, but in 1934, the building was purchased and repurposed as a theater. “The Kingdom of God” was the first play to appear on its stage and numerous other plays and musicals were performed for several decades. A fire damaged much of the playhouse in 1980, but it was quickly rebuilt and continues to feature excellent performances today.

9. Cape May Stage, Cape May, NJ

Though not originally a theater, the building that houses the Cape May Stage is a beautiful venue and has a long history dating back to 1853, when it was built as a Presbyterian church. In the 1980s, the building was taken over by a theater company and its first play was “The Dorothy Parker Story.” The Cape May Stage still holds numerous plays and the venue creates an intimate atmosphere for viewers.

10. McCarter Theatre Center, Princeton, NJ

The McCarter Theatre Center at Princeton University features three gorgeous theaters that are all notable in their own right. But the oldest theatre—opened in 1930—is definitely one to visit, with its 1,000 seats. The Matthews Theater is the main performance hall for the Princeton University Triangle Club.

New Jersey Search
View more New Jersey Theaters and Playhouses.
Visit a Theater or Playhouse Near You
Find Theaters and Playhouses Near You
23 Lake Shore Road, Budd Lake, NJ
The Founding of Pax AmicusBut Pax Amicus Theatre actually began seven years earlier. In 1970 Stan Barber and Bob Findlay (both are still residents ... Read More
4 Boland Drive, West Orange, NJ
OSPAC is a 501c3 non-profit organization with a dual mission: to present performances of the highest artistic quality for free or at a minimal cost... Read More
1020 Broad Street, Newark, NJ
Newark Symphony Hall enjoys a long and ruch cultural history as New Jersey's oldest and largest showcase for the arts, education and entertainment ... Read More
47 Erie Place, Nutley, NJ
History: Nutley Little Theatre’s history reaches back to the early thirties when a group of men, connected with the Grace Episcopal Church, ... Read More
179 Broadway, Long Branch, NJ
The New Jersey Repertory Company is a non-profit professional theater located on Broadway, in the heart of the ethnically diverse community of Long... Read More
The Barrow Mansion 83 Wayne Street, Jersey City, NJ
Mission The Attic Ensemble, Inc. is a non-profit producing organization committed to enriching, entertaining and inspiring Jersey City and the surr... Read More
173 Main Street, Manasquan, NJ
Mission Statement: Algonquin Arts Theatre (AAT) is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization founded in 1992 with the mission to provide cultural enhance... Read More
475 Demott Lane, Somerset, NJ
Mission Statement : The Villagers Theatre was founded in 1960 by twenty people who dedicated their organization to bringing ongoing cultural enri... Read More
99 Monmouth Street, Red Bank, NJ
The Count Basie Theatre, a 1926 historic theatre, is located in the heart of downtown Red Bank, New Jersey. Just minutes from the ocean, Red Bank i... Read More
21 Bridge Avenue, Red Bank, NJ
Mission: Two River Theater Company's mission is to perform from the world body of dramatic literature, including new works, those plays which most ... Read More
2 Bungalow Lane, Randolph, NJ
Brundage Park Playhouse is a non-profit organization sponsored by the Randolph Department of Parks, Recreation and Community Services.  It had... Read More
69 Elliott Street, Dover, NJ
About us: Many people are unaware of an intimate little theatre nestled in the hills of Dover called, of all things, The Dover Little Theatre. We a... Read More
123 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ
Live Entertainment! The Best of Broadway Comedies, Light Dramas, &Musicals!! Coffee, Fancy Desserts The First Avenue Playhouse is able to off... Read More
23 North Passaic Avenue, Chatham, NJ
Mission:The mission of the Chatham Community Players is to produce high quality theater for a diverse audience, while elevating our standard of exc... Read More
28 Walnut Street, Madison, NJ
Mission :   Founded in 1986, Playwrights Theatre is a 501(c) 3 not-for-profit professional theatre and arts education institution dedicated ... Read More
36 Madison Avenue, Madison, NJ
Mission and History: The Shakespeare Theatre of New Jersey is the state's largest professional theatre company dedicated to the presentation of Sh... Read More
130 Tomlinson Mill Road, Marlton, NJ
The theater is supported by a non-profit, independent foundation. The foundation board is committed to the continued growth and development of the ... Read More
32 Skyline Drive, Montville, NJ
History:In May 1928, the Mountain Lakes Dramatic Guild was founded by Arthur Stringer and a small group of local people dedicated to the idea that ... Read More
8 Marcella Avenue, West Orange, NJ
MissionFounded in 1981, the New Jersey Theatre Alliance supports a thriving professional theatre community with a wealth of resources.The first sta... Read More
Show More
Select a New Jersey town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you