New Jersey's 10 Best Live Theater Venues!

No matter how far technology takes us, it is unlikely that any gadget could ever capture the pure magic that is attending a live theater performance. The energy of the actors, the emotion of the story, the shared rapture of the audience, all combined to create a transformative, transfixing experience. Thankfully, residents of the Garden State can enjoy world class theater in our very backyard. From Shakespeare to Broadway, grand locations or community based gems, the theaters of New Jersey are ready and waiting to break a leg and blow you away. 

1. Paper Mill Playhouse, Milburn, NJ

Opened in 1938 in an already historic paper mill, this Milburn location has provided New Jersey with literally hundreds of world quality productions throughout the years. Playing host at various times to huge names such as Jane Fonda, Gene Wilder, Eva Gabor, Tony Danza, and Anne Hathaway, and with multiple original productions moving on to bigger stages, Paper Mill Playhouse has claimed its rightful place as King of New Jersey Theater. Visit today for old favorites, instant classics, and even select Autism-friendly performances. 

2. State Theatre New Jersey, New Brunswick, NJ

Attracting over 200,000 visitors annually, the State Theatre New Jersey is truly the culmination of decades of vision and dedication. Set beautifully in a converted vaudevillian and silent movie theater, this incredible organization puts forth productions for pleasure, education, and even families. Families can enjoy innovative relaxed performances, with modified lighting and the freedom to move about if necessary. More adult patrons can expect world class musicals, stand-up comedy, ballet, and riveting cultural performances.

3. Two River Theater, Red Bank, NJ

Two River Theater puts forth fabulous productions, but what really secures their spot near the top is a commitment to fostering the talent of emerging playwrights, and helping bring their stories to the world. Furthermore, this Red Bank gem works with schools to both introduce children to the theater, and assist at risk youth in communities throughout the region. Support both the arts and young people with a trip to Two River Theater. 

4. McCarter Theatre Center, Princeton, NJ

From classic favorites to daring innovation to community outreach, McCarter Theater Center brings a touch of brilliance to New Jersey. This Princeton location has seen the world premiere of works such as “Our Town,” and “You Can’t Take it With You,” and legendary stars such as Katharine Hepburn and Elaine Stritch have paced its stage. Every aspect of live entertainment approached by the McCarter Theater is carried out spectacularly, and they’ve tried their hand at just about everything. 

5. Bergen Performing Arts Center, Englewood, NJ

A not-for-profit dream of a theater. Bergen Performing Arts Center helps set the pace for quality theater in New Jersey, hosting over 200 events annually, and attracting over 150,000 patrons. Their performing arts school fosters creativity in children across the state with outreach programming, and has introduced countless young people to the joys of live theater. Consider supporting a true legacy with a visit to Bergen Performing Arts Center. 

6. Cape May Stage, Cape May, NJ

This member of the National Register of Historic Places continues to wow with sharp, quality theater and promising new talent. Be sure to check out their website before a visit, as Cape May Stage has paired with local restaurants to create discounted night-out packages, ideal for when you just have to try something new. 

7. The Shakespeare Theatre of New Jersey, Madison, NJ

A 308-seat theater, with none measuring more than 32 feet from the stage, make the Shakespeare Theater of New Jersey one of the most intimately breathtaking ways to take in live theater. As the state’s only theater dedicated to the Bar, this Madison location can claim uniqueness as well. Originally a summer stock situation in Cape May, the Shakespeare Theater of New Jersey can today safely be called a world-class option for live performances. 

8. Broadway Theater, Pitman, NJ

Diverse productions, talented cast and crew, and a commitment to quality theater makes Broadway Theater an easy add to our list. This truly gorgeous Pitman location has hosted some of entertainment’s brightest stars throughout the years, from George Burns to George Carlin. Catch tomorrow’s icons early and take in a production at Broadway Theater. 

9. George Street Playhouse, New Brunswick, NJ

Since 1974, George Street Playhouse has brought both mainstream productions and issue-oriented theater to New Jersey, transforming a former supermarket into a world class stage. Recently rehomed to the former state museum of agriculture, George Street Playhouse is dedicated to continuing both quality theater in the state of New Jersey, and a love of the stage in her residents. 

10. Plays-In-The-Park, Edison, NJ

As perhaps the most pleasant manner of enjoying live theater in New Jersey, Plays-In-The-Park hosts three full-scale musicals per annum in their incredible amphitheater in Edison. This incredible, affordable (children under 12 are free and adult tickets cost just $7) option for live theater is a great way to be thoroughly entertained, introduce children to theater, and spend some time outdoors. 

New Jersey Search
View more New Jersey Theaters and Playhouses.
Visit a Theater or Playhouse Near You
Find Theaters and Playhouses Near You
23 Lake Shore Road, Budd Lake, NJ
The Founding of Pax AmicusBut Pax Amicus Theatre actually began seven years earlier. In 1970 Stan Barber and Bob Findlay (both are still residents ... Read More
4 Boland Drive, West Orange, NJ
OSPAC is a 501c3 non-profit organization with a dual mission: to present performances of the highest artistic quality for free or at a minimal cost... Read More
1020 Broad Street, Newark, NJ
Newark Symphony Hall enjoys a long and ruch cultural history as New Jersey's oldest and largest showcase for the arts, education and entertainment ... Read More
47 Erie Place, Nutley, NJ
History: Nutley Little Theatre’s history reaches back to the early thirties when a group of men, connected with the Grace Episcopal Church, ... Read More
179 Broadway, Long Branch, NJ
The New Jersey Repertory Company is a non-profit professional theater located on Broadway, in the heart of the ethnically diverse community of Long... Read More
The Barrow Mansion 83 Wayne Street, Jersey City, NJ
Mission The Attic Ensemble, Inc. is a non-profit producing organization committed to enriching, entertaining and inspiring Jersey City and the surr... Read More
173 Main Street, Manasquan, NJ
Mission Statement: Algonquin Arts Theatre (AAT) is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization founded in 1992 with the mission to provide cultural enhance... Read More
475 Demott Lane, Somerset, NJ
Mission Statement : The Villagers Theatre was founded in 1960 by twenty people who dedicated their organization to bringing ongoing cultural enri... Read More
99 Monmouth Street, Red Bank, NJ
The Count Basie Theatre, a 1926 historic theatre, is located in the heart of downtown Red Bank, New Jersey. Just minutes from the ocean, Red Bank i... Read More
21 Bridge Avenue, Red Bank, NJ
Mission: Two River Theater Company's mission is to perform from the world body of dramatic literature, including new works, those plays which most ... Read More
2 Bungalow Lane, Randolph, NJ
Brundage Park Playhouse is a non-profit organization sponsored by the Randolph Department of Parks, Recreation and Community Services.  It had... Read More
69 Elliott Street, Dover, NJ
About us: Many people are unaware of an intimate little theatre nestled in the hills of Dover called, of all things, The Dover Little Theatre. We a... Read More
123 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ
Live Entertainment! The Best of Broadway Comedies, Light Dramas, &Musicals!! Coffee, Fancy Desserts The First Avenue Playhouse is able to off... Read More
23 North Passaic Avenue, Chatham, NJ
Mission:The mission of the Chatham Community Players is to produce high quality theater for a diverse audience, while elevating our standard of exc... Read More
28 Walnut Street, Madison, NJ
Mission :   Founded in 1986, Playwrights Theatre is a 501(c) 3 not-for-profit professional theatre and arts education institution dedicated ... Read More
36 Madison Avenue, Madison, NJ
Mission and History: The Shakespeare Theatre of New Jersey is the state's largest professional theatre company dedicated to the presentation of Sh... Read More
130 Tomlinson Mill Road, Marlton, NJ
The theater is supported by a non-profit, independent foundation. The foundation board is committed to the continued growth and development of the ... Read More
32 Skyline Drive, Montville, NJ
History:In May 1928, the Mountain Lakes Dramatic Guild was founded by Arthur Stringer and a small group of local people dedicated to the idea that ... Read More
8 Marcella Avenue, West Orange, NJ
MissionFounded in 1981, the New Jersey Theatre Alliance supports a thriving professional theatre community with a wealth of resources.The first sta... Read More
Show More
Select a New Jersey town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you